Serving Injured Clients In Wisconsin With Legal Experience You Can Trust
I am a strong advocate for injured clients, focused on maximizing your recovery and resolving your case efficiently through skilled negotiation and, when needed, litigation. Whether you have a personal injury or worker’s compensation claim, you will work directly with me, Peter Carman. My dual experience on both sides of the courtroom, including for insurance defense, helps me anticipate insurer tactics and strengthen your claim.
Strong Legal Advocacy From Consultation To Resolution For Wisconsin Clients
Read More About My Law Firm’s Practice Areas

Personal Injury Claims
Speak with a caring lawyer about your accident injuries.

Auto Accident Injuries
Car and truck crashes and other motor vehicle collisions can cause life-changing injuries.

Worker's Compensation
You have a right to full and fair compensation for your workplace injuries.
Get Personal Attention From An Experienced Personal Injury And Worker’s Compensation Lawyer
Every personal injury or worker’s compensation claim I handle receives my full attention, and I commit the resources needed to do it right. At the Law Office of Peter J. Carman, S.C., you will get a prompt, candid and accurate assessment of your injury claim. While you focus on healing, I will manage the legal work. I am prepared and equipped to take on complex personal injury cases.
I pursue every category of damages available, including past, current and future medical costs, lost wages, pain and suffering, and disability. I also evaluate how the incident affects your family life in the whole picture. When warranted, I will seek damages for loss of society, companionship and services for your spouse and children. Much of my time is spent engaging with insurers, health care providers and corporations on your behalf.
What My Clients Are Saying
“Peter Carman has been my lawyer through a five-year and still ongoing jury trial involving a motor vehicle crash that happened when I was 16 years old. The process of recovering from a life-altering crash is hard enough at that young an age, but then needing to worry about insurance offices and medical bills in addition is almost unbearable. Mr. Carman stood by my mom and I’s side as we navigated the initial medical bills, the following back and forth with the insurance offices, and then finally, the four-day jury trial in which we were awarded a sum far beyond what the insurance company was willing to pay. Peter is diligent and organized, stern when necessary, and, most importantly, an empathetic person who genuinely cares that your case succeeds. He will defend your case and ensure that he is as up-to-date on the relevant material as possible, and he will defend you as a person, a whole person, too. I put my faith in Peter Carman, and I couldn’t be happier with the results.”
– Brooklyn
“I hope no one ever has to go toe to toe with worker’s comp companies. If you do, you will quickly realize that it’s laden with headaches, heartaches, and nothing is ever simple. Peter is an honest lawyer who will not be afraid to tell you if your case is winnable. In the event that Peter does take your case, you can rest assured that you will get his best to make sure you do receive the compensation you deserve.”
– Kong Lee
“Attorney Peter Carman was such a blessing to me in a very dark time in my life. For once it felt like I truly had an advocate who really listened to me and my story, and at some points, he cared more about me and my life than I did. Pete made sure to make me get back into see the doctors when my PTSD got bad again. If your life has been forcefully altered because of an accident/injury, do yourself the biggest favor you could possibly do and contact his office. He sincerely cares about his clients, and he sees you for the whole person that you are; you’re not just another number to him. He’s a top-notch attorney and incredibly knowledgeable when it comes to the insurance industry. God forbid something happened to one of my friends or family members, I wouldn’t send them anywhere else because I know Pete will fight for them.”
– Nathan
“Attorney Peter Carman is passionate about helping injured victims. His commitment to me via his integrity, diligence, knowledge of the law and persistence establish him above the rest. He is comprehensive, strategic and always one step ahead. Peter’s attention and detail to my case made it known I had the best advocate to care, keep me informed, fight for me and be the voice I needed to represent me against the opposing party and their attorney. He carried the burden of an uneasy and uncertain process which allowed me to focus on my healing. Peter is a powerful opponent who understands what is required to get the job done and do so with professionalism and tenacity.”
– Lisa S
“When I called Peter he answered all my Work Comp questions. Made an appointment went to his office Peter was very professional. He explained everything to me in detail. Hired him that same day. He did a very good job on my case. I recommend him to anyone looking for a Work Comp attorney.”
– JoAnne
“Outstanding attorney, diligently advocated on my behalf over three years in a workman’s compensation claim. Attorney Carman responded to any concern or questions within minutes majority of the time (including outside business hours/weekends). I would recommend anyone requiring legal representation on a personal/work injury case to consult and retain Attorney Peter Carman, who will always put your needs and best interest above his.”
– Jennifer
Protecting Injured Workers And Their Futures
As an experienced Wisconsin worker’s compensation attorney, I help you understand your rights and legal options to seek the full benefits you are entitled to. In today’s environment, insurers frequently delay or deny valid claims. Many employers look for ways to terminate workers after a back, neck, head, shoulder, knee or other job-related injury.
I will make sure your outstanding medical bills and any related liens are addressed in settlement discussions. I can also assist you in securing additional resources, including health insurance, wage loss benefits and vocational retraining.
In some situations, your work injury may also give rise to a separate personal injury claim against a negligent third party. For example, if you are hurt in a motor vehicle collision while on the job, you may be able to pursue compensation from the at fault driver and their auto insurer. If your injury occurs while you are on the job, or your serious illness resulted from your working conditions, let me help you seek worker’s compensation benefits.
Effective And Aggressive Representation: Case Results
2025: Obtained an over 1.8 million jury verdict in an auto crash resulting in a traumatic brain injury (mTBI/concussion) and PTSD case
2025: Obtained a $1.1 million combined limits settlement pre-suit in a serious physical injury with scaring hit-and-run motor vehicle versus pedestrian case.
2024: Obtained a $650,000 settlement in a personal injury case involving traumatically induced osteoarthritis of an ankle with an arthroscopic surgery.
2023: Obtained a $500,000 settlement in a personal injury case involving multiple back surgeries.
2023: Obtained a $240,000 (out of an available $250,000 in insurance policy limits) pre-suit personal injury settlement in a serious physical injury motor vehicle accident case.
2022: Obtained a $500,000 pre-suit personal injury insurance policy limits settlement in a traumatic brain injury case.
2022: Obtained a $250,000 settlement in a worker’s compensation permanent total disability case.
2021: Obtained a $265,000 settlement in a worker’s compensation vocational retraining case.
$300,0002019: Obtained a $300,000 pre-suit personal injury settlement in a traumatic brain injury case.
Peer-Recognition For Legal Excellence
My legal peers’ nominations have resulted in accolades such as AV Preeminent peer-review rating* through Martindale-Hubbell, the highest rating, from 2019-present. I have also received lead counsel verification and been included in Wisconsin’s Super Lawyers Rising Stars list in 2006 and 2010-2012, the Super Lawyers list in 2022-2025, and recently recognized by my peers in the 31st and 32nd editions of The Best Lawyers in America® for my exceptional work in Workers’ Compensation Law – Claimants and Litigation – Insurance.
*AV®, AV Preeminent®, Martindale-Hubbell Distinguished and Martindale-Hubbell Notable are certification marks used under license in accordance with the Martindale-Hubbell certification procedures, standards and policies. Martindale-Hubbell® is the facilitator of a peer review rating process. Ratings reflect the anonymous opinions of members of the bar and the judiciary. Martindale-Hubbell® Peer Review Ratings™ fall into two categories – legal ability and general ethical standards.
While I cannot guarantee the exact outcome of your claim, no attorney can, my reputation and history of successful litigation speaks for itself.
Contact Me Today: I Have A Proven Track Record With Significant Results
At Law Office of Peter J. Carman, S.C., I intentionally limit the number of cases I work on so I can give you personal attention, direct communication and dedicated advocacy from start to finish of your claim. If you are hurt by someone’s negligence or have work-related injuries, contact me. I will leverage my trial skills and deep insight gained from over two decades of legal practice in seeking a positive outcome for you.
When you engage my legal services, you will speak with me, and not a go-between, as I aim to seek justice and compensation for your injuries. Your case is my cause, and I’m ready to fight for your recovery. I am easy to contact. While primarily serving northeast Wisconsin and the Fox Cities area, I also accept cases throughout Wisconsin. Call my office in Appleton at 920-770-1608 or email me to schedule your free case evaluation.
At Law Office of Peter J. Carman, S.C., I offer proven, peer-respected legal advocacy for injured clients.



















